“She’s on her own”: a thematic analysis of clinicians’ comments on abortion referral

Nazeneen Homaifar, Lori Freedman,Valerie French

“She's on her own”: a thematic analysis of clinicians' comments on abortion referral

Abstract

Objective

The objective was to understand the motivations around and practices of abortion referral among women’s health providers.

Methods

We analyzed the written comments from a survey of Nebraska physicians and advanced-practice clinicians in family medicine and obstetrics-gynecology about their referral practices and opinions for a woman seeking an abortion. We analyzed clinician’s responses to open-ended questions on abortion referral thematically.

Results

Of the 496 completed surveys, 431 had comments available for analysis. We found four approaches to abortion referral: (a) facilitating a transfer of care, (b) providing the abortion clinic name or phone number, (c) no referral and (4) misleading referrals to clinicians or facilities that do not provide abortion care. Clinicians described many motivations for their manner of referral, including a fiduciary obligation to refer, empathy for the patient, respect for patient autonomy and the lack of need for referral. We found that abortion stigma impacts referral as clinicians explained that patients often desire additional privacy and clinicians themselves seek to avoid tension among their staff. Other clinicians would not provide an abortion referral, citing moral or religious objections or stating they did not know where to refer women seeking abortion. Some respondents would refer women to other providers for additional evaluation or counseling before an abortion, while others sought to dissuade the woman from obtaining an abortion.

Conclusions

While practices and motivations varied, few clinicians facilitated referral for abortion beyond verbally naming a clinic if an abortion referral was made at all.

Implications

Interprofessional leadership, enhanced clinician training and public policy that addresses conscientious refusal of abortion referral are needed to reduce abortion stigma and ensure that women can access safe care.


Homaifar N, Freedman L,French V. “She’s on her own”: a thematic analysis of clinicians’ comments on abortion referral. Contraception. 2017 May;95(5):470-476. doi: 10.1016/j.contraception.2017.01.007. Epub 2017 Jan 25.

One thought on ““She’s on her own”: a thematic analysis of clinicians’ comments on abortion referral”

  1. “She’s on her own” appears to be an editorial comment placed within quotation marks in the title, not a comment made by a survey respondent. The comment does not appear in returns reported in the paper from survey respondents. An email from the Project Adminstrator to Prof. Freedman requesting clarification of this point was not answered.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *